ABIM's Evaluations and Judgments
Candidates for Board Certification and Maintenance of Certification agree that their professional qualifications, including their moral and ethical standing in the medical profession and their competence in clinical skills, will be evaluated by ABIM, and ABIM's good faith judgment concerning such matters will be final.
ABIM may make inquiry of persons named in candidates' applications and of other persons, such as authorities of licensing bodies, hospitals or other institutions as ABIM may deem appropriate with respect to such matters. Candidates agree that ABIM may provide information it has concerning them to others whom ABIM judges to have a legitimate need for it.
ABIM makes academic and scientific judgments in its evaluations of the results of its examinations. Situations may occur, even through no fault of the candidates, that render examination results unreliable in the judgment of ABIM. Candidates agree that if ABIM determines that, in its judgment, the results of their examination are unreliable, ABIM may require the candidates to retake an examination at its next administration or other time designated by ABIM.
ABIM also may evaluate candidates' or diplomates' fitness for Board Certification – including their professionalism, ethics and integrity — in disciplinary matters, and ABIM's good faith judgment concerning such matters will be final.
As of July 2012, the American Board of Internal Medicine considers all internal medicine and subspecialist physicians who have met the standards for Board Certification in general internal medicine or any of its subspecialties to be “Board Eligible” in the relevant specialty for a period of seven years. The seven-year period of Board Eligibility shall begin upon the candidate's successful completion of the initial certification requirements in their field or July 1, 2012, whichever is later. During the period of Board Eligibility, the candidate may apply for the certifying examination in the relevant specialty. If the candidate does not become Board Certified during the seven-year period of Board Eligibility, the candidate will no longer be deemed “Board Eligible” and may no longer represent himself or herself as “Board Eligible.”
A candidate who is no longer Board Eligible may nevertheless apply for a certifying examination, but only if the candidate has: (i) completed a year of retraining in the relevant specialty after the expiry of the candidate's period of Board Eligibility, but no more than seven years before the application; and (ii) met all other requirements for Board Certification in effect at that time. Retraining will require the successful completion of one year of additional residency/fellowship training in an ACGME-accredited U.S. training program or an RCPSC-accredited Canadian training program and an attestation from the program that the candidate has demonstrated the requisite competency for unsupervised practice. The Board Eligibility policy may be subject to other ABIM policies, including the Re-examination policy.
The Board recognizes that extraordinary circumstances — such as military deployment or illness — may prevent a trainee from completing the requirements for Board Certification in the seven-year period of Board Eligibility. In such extraordinary cases the candidate may appeal for an extension of the seven-year period. Any such appeal will be adjudicated by the Staff Credentials Committee of the Board, and the decision of the Staff Credentials Committee will be the final decision of the Board.
Beginning in 2011, candidates who are unsuccessful on an examination may apply for re-examination as set forth below. To be granted admission, candidates must meet all applicable licensure, professional standing, underlying certifications and procedural requirements. Candidates who fail three consecutive initial certification exams in the same discipline over three years will not be permitted to take an exam in that discipline during the next annual exam administration. Only exam failures occurring in 2011 and thereafter will count toward the three examination limit.
- A candidate who is unsuccessful on the Internal Medicine Certification Exam in 2014, 2015, and 2016 would need to wait until the 2018 administration of the exam to re-apply for admission.
Candidates who fail one or two consecutive initial certification exams in the same discipline and do not register for the exam in the third consecutive year will not be subject to this policy. They will be able to register for the exam the next time it is offered, and the three consecutive attempt cycle will begin again.
- A candidate who is unsuccessful in passing the Internal Medicine Certification Exam in 2015 and 2016 and does not register or cancel the exam in 2017 will be able to register for the exam in 2018.
This policy applies only to ABIM initial certification exams offered annually; it does not apply to initial certification exams offered every other year. The policy does not apply to the Sports Medicine Certification Exam and the Adolescent Medicine Certification Exam, which are administered by other ABMS Boards, or to ABIM Maintenance of Certification Exams.
ABIM strictly enforces this policy and does not permit exceptions or appeals.
Reporting Certification Status
ABIM, in addition to reporting certification status, reports whether or not diplomates are participating in MOC.
On a candidate's written request to ABIM, the following information may also be provided in writing: (1) that an application for Board Certification or Maintenance of Certification is currently in process and/or (2) the year the candidate was last admitted to an examination.
Reporting Board Eligibility
ABIM does not confirm or report the Board Eligibility status of its candidates. Parties interested in a candidate's Board Eligibility status may wish to communicate directly with the candidate and/or with the appropriate training program.
Representation of Board Certification and Board Eligibility Status
Physicians must accurately state their ABIM Board Certification or Board Eligibility status at all times. This includes descriptions in curriculum vitae, advertisements, publications, directories and letterheads.
Please note: ABIM does not authorize the use of its logo by others. Diplomates with expired time-limited certification or those whose certification is suspended or revoked may not claim ABIM Board Certification and must revise all descriptions of their qualifications accordingly. Additionally, a candidate who does not meet the requirements for Board Eligibility set forth above may not represent himself or herself as Board Eligible. Diplomates who have multiple certifications and allow one of them to lapse should revise their public materials (letterhead, business cards, advertisements, etc.) to reflect those certifications that are currently valid.
A physician who misrepresents his or her Board Certification or Board Eligibility status may be subject to disciplinary sanctions, including the revocation or suspension of the physician's Board Certification or eligibility to participate in Board Certification or Maintenance of Certification processes.
Errors and Disruptions in Examination Administration
Occasionally problems occur in the creation, administration and scoring of examinations. For example, power failures, hardware and software problems, human errors or weather problems may interfere with some part of the examination process. When problems occur and ABIM determines that they have compromised the integrity of the examination results, ABIM will provide affected candidates with an opportunity for re-examination.
A candidate who believes that testing conditions or other examination administration issues have adversely affected the candidate's ability to take and complete an examination should notify the proctor at the test center, or contact ABIM as soon as possible after the exam. In no event will ABIM consider a request to cancel an examination result after the result has been released to the candidate.
Re-examination shall be the candidate's sole remedy. ABIM shall not be liable for inconvenience, expense or other damage caused by any problems in the creation, administration or scoring of an examination, including the need for retesting or delays in score reporting. In no circumstance will ABIM reduce its standards as a means of correcting a problem in examination administration.
ABIM considers the certification or recertification status of its candidates and diplomates to be public information.
ABIM provides a diplomate's Board Certification status, Maintenance of Certification and personal identifying information, including mailing address, e-mail address and last four digits of a diplomate's Social Security number, to the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB), the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) (which publishes The Official ABMS Directory of Board Certified Medical Specialists), and to other credential and licensure verification organizations. FSMB uses personal identifying information, including the last four digits of Social Security numbers, as unique internal identifiers and is required to maintain the confidentiality of this information. ABMS also uses the last four digits of Social Security numbers as unique internal identifiers, and publishes other personal identifying information (but not Social Security numbers) for purposes of The Official ABMS Directory of Board Certified Medical Specialists. ABMS contacts diplomates directly to verify the accuracy of the information published in the directory and to obtain consent to publish such information. On request, ABIM provides a diplomate's Board Certification and Maintenance of Certification status and address to professional medical societies and other organizations that provide ABIM-sanctioned educational resources and products used for Self-Evaluation of Medical Knowledge or Practice Assessment in the Maintenance of Certification program.
ABIM provides residency and fellowship training program directors with information about a trainee's prior training and pass/fail status on certifying examinations. If a trainee has given permission, ABIM will provide the program director with the trainee's score on his/her first attempt at the Certification examination for that area of training. ABIM uses examination performance, training program evaluations, outcomes-based milestones for resident performance, Self-Evaluation of Medical Knowledge and Practice Assessment, and other information for its determination of eligibility and qualification of candidates for certification, for evaluation of resident development and performance, and/or for research and related purposes. In any such research, ABIM will not identify specific individuals, hospitals or practice associations. Candidates acknowledge and agree that examination performance and milestones data may be shared by and between ABIM and ACGME. All practice performance data is HIPAA-compliant.
ABIM reserves the right to disclose information it possesses about any individual whom it judges has violated ABIM rules, engaged in misrepresentation or unprofessional behavior, or shows signs of impairment.
The ability to practice medicine is a fundamental tenet of Board Certification. Candidates for Board Certification and Maintenance of Certification must possess a permanent, valid, unrestricted and unchallenged medical license in the United States, its territories or Canada. Physicians practicing exclusively abroad and who do not hold a U.S. or Canadian license must hold a license where they practice and provide documentation from the relevant licensing authority that their license is in good standing and without conditions or restrictions. Restrictions include but are not limited to conditions, contingencies, probation, limitations and stipulated agreements.
A physician with a restricted, suspended, revoked or surrendered license in any jurisdiction is not eligible to be certified or admitted to a certification examination.
ABIM will suspend or revoke the Board Certification of any diplomate who has a license that is suspended, revoked, surrendered or restricted (whether voluntarily or otherwise) so as to prohibit the practice of medicine in one or more jurisdictions, and no valid license in any other jurisdiction. A diplomate who has a license that is suspended, revoked, surrendered or restricted (whether voluntarily or otherwise) so as to prohibit the practice of medicine in one or more jurisdictions, but who continues to hold a valid license in another jurisdiction—or a diplomate whose license in any jurisdiction has been restricted—may be subject to disciplinary sanctions, including the suspension or revocation of the physician’s Board Certification.
ABIM recognizes that some candidates have physical limitations that make it impossible for them to fulfill the requirement for proficiency in performing procedures. For such individuals, the procedural skills requirement may be waived. Program directors should write to ABIM for an exception before the individual enters training or when the disability becomes established.
ABIM is committed to offering suitable examination accommodations for all candidates, including individuals with disabilities. When necessary, alternative arrangements under conditions comparable to those provided for other candidates are offered to disabled individuals. Candidates who need accommodation for a disability during an examination must provide a written request to ABIM and documentation must be received by ABIM no later than the examination registration deadline. Reapplication for special accommodation is not required for each examination administration unless a new accommodation is requested. ABIM treats requests for accommodations as confidential. For additional information about the process and documentation requirements, please contact ABIM at email@example.com, or refer to Take the Exam: Accommodation for Test Takers with Disabilities.
If a candidate or a diplomate has a history of substance abuse, documentation of at least one year of continuous sobriety from a reliable monitoring source may be required for admission to an examination or to receive a certificate. ABIM treats such information as confidential.
Those who take ABIM examinations have a continuing obligation to maintain examination confidentiality. See Copyright and Examination Non-Disclosure Policy on the inside cover of this document.
All ABIM examinations are administered in secure testing centers by test administrators who are responsible for maintaining the integrity and security of the certification process. Test administrators are required to report to ABIM any irregular or improper behavior by a candidate, such as giving or obtaining information or aid, looking at the test material of others, removing examination materials from the test center, taking notes, bringing unauthorized items, including electronic devices (e.g., pagers, cell phones, tablets, PDAs, etc.), into the examination, failing to comply with time limits or instructions, talking or other disruptive behavior.
Test administrators may intervene to stop any of the foregoing. In addition, as part of its effort to assure exam integrity, ABIM utilizes data forensic techniques that use statistical analyses of test-response data to identify patterns of test fraud, including cheating and copyright infringement. ABIM investigates all reports of irregular or improper activity.
Irregular or improper behavior in examinations that is observed, made apparent by data forensics or statistical analysis, or uncovered by other means will be considered a subversion of the certification process and will constitute grounds for invalidation of a candidate's examination and subject the candidate to disciplinary sanctions, including suspension or revocation of Board Certification or eligibility to participate in Board Certification or Maintenance of Certification processes. Failure to fully cooperate with an ABIM investigation is considered unprofessional conduct and constitutes grounds for disciplinary sanctions.
Disciplinary Sanctions and Appeals
ABIM may, at its discretion, rescind a diplomate's Board Certification if the diplomate was not qualified to receive the certificate at the time it was issued, even if the certificate was issued as a result of a mistake on the part of ABIM.
ABIM may impose disciplinary sanctions, including the suspension or revocation of Board Certification or participation in Certification or Maintenance of Certification processes, invalidation of an examination, or other professional sanctions, if ABIM obtains evidence that in its judgment demonstrates that a candidate or diplomate: (1) has had a license to practice medicine restricted in any jurisdiction, has surrendered a license but continues to hold a valid license in another jurisdiction, or has had one or more licenses suspended or revoked but continues to hold a valid license; (2) engaged in irregular or improper behavior or other misconduct in connection with an ABIM examination; (3) made a material misstatement of fact or omission in connection to ABIM with an application, or misrepresented his or her Board Certification or Board Eligibility status to anyone; (4) failed to maintain moral, ethical or professional behavior satisfactory to ABIM; or (5) engaged in misconduct that adversely affects professional competence or integrity.
In the event ABIM obtains such evidence, it shall so notify the physician in writing. Such notification shall: (1) advise the physician that the ABIM Credentials and Certification Committee (“CCC”) will determine on behalf of ABIM, no fewer than 45 days after the date of the notice, whether to recommend any disciplinary sanction; (2) summarize the evidence in ABIM's possession; (3) include copies of any documentary evidence in ABIM's possession; (4) provide the physician an opportunity to make a written submission to the CCC; (5) disclose the policy(ies) and/or procedure(s) pursuant to which ABIM may recommend a sanction, and the possible sanction(s); (6) advise the physician that the failure to respond timely to the notice may be considered unprofessional and weighed against the physician by the CCC; and (7) advise the physician that if the CCC recommends a sanction, the physician would have a right of appeal with an in-person or telephonic hearing before a panel designated by ABIM's Board of Directors.
In the event the CCC determines to recommend a disciplinary sanction, it shall so notify the physician in writing. Such notification will: (1) set forth the factual bases for such determination; (2) summarize the reasons for such determination; (3) advise the physician of his or her right to request an appeal of the CCC's determination; (4) advise the physician that any request for an appeal must be submitted to ABIM within 30 days of the date of the notice of the CCC's determination; (5) provide procedural information about the appeal process; (6) advise the physician that if a hearing is requested, ABIM will provide notice of the members of the appeal panel and the date, time and if applicable, place of the hearing at least 45 days in advance of the hearing; and (7) advise the physician that while a recommended sanction is not final and does not affect a physician's Board Certification status, a physician who is subject to a recommended sanction is not eligible to participate in the Certification process. If a physician declines to appeal a recommended sanction, the recommended sanction determined by the CCC shall become the final decision of ABIM.
An appeal of a recommended sanction shall be determined by a panel consisting of three non-ABIM employee physicians designated by ABIM's Board of Directors and including at least one member of the Board of Directors (an “Appeal Panel”). An Appeal Panel shall have the discretion to affirm, rescind or modify a recommended sanction, or impose an alternative sanction. In advance of each appeal hearing ABIM shall provide each member of the Appeal Panel and the physician appellant with copies of the documentary record for the physician's sanction and appeal proceeding. In its consideration of an appeal of a recommended sanction, an Appeal Panel shall not be bound by any technical rules of evidence, shall consider any information timely submitted by or on behalf of the physician at any stage of the proceeding, and shall hold a hearing. At an appeal hearing, the physician and/or the physician's counsel may present information and, subject to the Appeal Panel's discretion, witnesses. ABIM's counsel may ask questions of the physician, the physician's counsel and any witnesses. Appeal hearings shall be transcribed by a professional stenographer. After reaching a decision, an Appeal Panel shall notify the physician of its decision in writing. Such written decision shall include the factual bases of the decision and a summary of the reasons for the decision. The decision of the majority of an Appeal Panel shall be the final decision of ABIM.
The foregoing sanction and appeal procedures shall apply to matters arising on or after July 1, 2013. Earlier arising matters will be handled in accordance with ABIM's policies and procedures previously in effect.
Notwithstanding these procedures, ABIM reserves the right to revoke or suspend a diplomate's Board Certification summarily in extraordinary circumstances.
ABIM, in its sole discretion, may notify local credentialing bodies, licensing bodies, law enforcement agencies, program directors, impaired physicians advocacy groups, or others of any final disciplinary sanctions.
To regain Board Certification after a suspension, the physician must comply with such conditions as ABIM may impose and successfully complete ABIM's Maintenance of Certification program.
Copyright and Examination Non-Disclosure Policy
All ABIM materials are protected by the federal Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 101, et seq. Access to all such materials, as further detailed below, is strictly conditioned upon agreement to abide by ABIM's rights under the Copyright Act and to maintain examination confidentiality.
ABIM examinations are confidential, in addition to being protected by federal copyright and trade secret laws. Candidates and diplomates who undertake examinations agree that they will not copy, reproduce, adapt, disclose, or transmit examinations, in whole or in part, before or after taking an examination, by any means now known or hereafter invented. They further agree that they will not reconstruct examination content from memory, by dictation, or by any other means or otherwise discuss examination content with others. Candidates and Diplomates further acknowledge that disclosure or any other use of ABIM examination content constitutes professional misconduct and may expose them to criminal as well as civil liability, and may also result in ABIM's imposition of penalties against them, including but not limited to, invalidation of examination results, exclusion from future examinations, suspension or revocation of Board Certification and other sanctions.
With respect to ABIM's Maintenance of Certification (MOC) products, including its Medical Knowledge Modules and ABIM PIMs Practice Improvement Modules®, candidates agree that they will not copy, reproduce or make any adaptations of such materials in any manner; and will not assist someone else in the infringement or misuse of these or any other ABIM-copyrighted works.
Competency in Technology
Consistent with the ABMS/ACGME General Competencies in Systems-Based Practice, ABIM requires its candidates and diplomates to possess sufficient competencies in information technology, including the use of personal computers, the Internet, and e-mail, for correspondence and completion of examinations and modules throughout their participation in ABIM Certification and Maintenance of Certification programs.