More than half of physician disciplinary actions in California study involved gaps in medical knowledge
Researchers discuss possibility of using assessment to identify knowledge gaps that may be remediable, potentially reducing disciplinary actions that adversely affect patient care
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 16, 2026 — Gaps in medical knowledge, such as prescribing inappropriate medications, incorrectly interpreting imaging studies or ordering an unnecessary high-risk procedure that could jeopardize a patient’s health, played a role in 52.3% of the physician disciplinary actions reviewed in a new American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) study published in the Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions.
The study also found that physicians disciplined for a knowledge-related reason were less likely to have passed the ABIM Internal Medicine Certification Exam on their first attempt—the test internists need to pass to earn certification.
“Medicine changes continuously, and keeping pace with new evidence and standards of care is essential to patient safety,” said study co-author Lorna Lynn, MD, ABIM Senior Vice President for Health Equity and Medical Assessment Engagement. “Doctors can continue learning throughout their careers, and the association between exam performance and knowledge-related disciplinary actions points to the potential for assessment to identify and address gaps before they may place patients at risk.”
Researchers reviewed 558 disciplinary actions involving doctors with an ABIM identification number in California from 2011 to 2022, using publicly available state medical board records to identify which involved knowledge gaps.
Among the 558 disciplined physicians, researchers analyzed exam performance for 239 who first took the ABIM certification exam between 1996 and 2022. Of those disciplined for a knowledge gap, 66.7% had passed on their first attempt, compared with 78.0% of those disciplined for other reasons, such as DUI and fraud convictions and inappropriate relationships with patients. Physician discipline from medical boards can include sanctions ranging from a public reprimand or probation to revocation of a medical license.
California was selected for the study because it has the nation’s largest number of active physicians and because its licensing board releases detailed descriptions of disciplinary actions.
The findings build on earlier research showing a link between performance on the Maintenance of Certification (MOC) exam—which doctors take after becoming board certified to demonstrate that they have kept their medical knowledge current—and physician disciplinary actions. Physicians who did not pass the MOC exam within 10 years of becoming board certified, including those who did not take it, had more than twice the rate of state medical board disciplinary actions as those who passed. Higher exam scores were also linked to lower rates of disciplinary action.
“When people hear that a doctor has faced disciplinary action, they may think of misconduct or unprofessional behavior; they may not think about gaps in what a doctor knows,” said lead author Lauren M. Duhigg, MPH, ABIM Senior Research Associate. “Our findings suggest medical knowledge deficits may play a larger role in physician disciplinary actions than many people realize, and these gaps have the potential to directly impact patient care.”
###
About the American Board of Internal Medicine
Since its founding in 1936, certification by the American Board of Internal Medicine (ABIM) has stood for the highest standard in internal medicine and its 20 subspecialties. Nearly 300,000 physicians are certified by ABIM, representing more than a quarter of all doctors in the United States. Patients whose doctors demonstrate more medical knowledge and judgment through ABIM certification and Maintenance of Certification have better prognoses on a host of outcomes. Visit the ABIM Blog to learn more and follow ABIM on LinkedIn and Instagram. ABIM is a Member Board of the American Board of Medical Specialties.
Media Contact
Katie Park
kpark@abim.org